Advertisement
Shutter Stock - Licensed Images
__________________________________________________________________________________
I first discovered Styx in the 1980s, sitting in the backseat of my parents’ car, fiddling with the radio dial. I was young, and one song in particular — “Too Much Time on My Hands” — caught my attention. At the time, I didn’t fully understand the lyrics, especially the part where they sang:
"Now I'm a jet fuel genius, I can solve the world's problems
Without even trying
I've got dozens of friends and the fun never ends That is, as long as I'm buying."
Later I could recall my neighbor laughing during that portion of the song. It wasn’t until later in life that I realized how perfectly those words captured the feeling of idle ambition and overconfidence — and why the song resonated so deeply. It was “Too Much Time on My Hands” that truly made me a fan of Styx.
As their music evolved, I must admit I was a bit disappointed. Their classic, signature sound gradually melded into the electronic, modernized production that many other bands were experimenting with at the time. In my humble opinion, despite the success of “Mr. Roboto” and the curiosity it generated, that shift marked the beginning of a decline. Honestly, Styx didn’t need to change a thing. Some recipes for success are timeless, and their original formula — theatrical, melodic, and grandly ambitious — didn’t need any tampering.
Throughout time I have heard rumblings of why Styx broke up. It doesn’t matter at this point. However, it certainly did when the band first split. I am not certain, if it was this band specifically or the culmination of what was happening all over the world of music. Many great bands were parting ways. It seemed as if the quality of music would be gone forever. Thankfully, that didn’t happen.
The Guitar Thrills discovery | Styx and the fundamentals
Styx began in Chicago in the early 1970s, initially performing under the name TW4 before adopting the Styx name in 1972. Their first three albums showcased a progressive-rock foundation but didn’t gain major commercial traction. The band’s early lineup shifted when guitarist John Curulewski left in 1975, prompting the arrival of Tommy Shaw, whose addition helped define what fans now consider the “classic” Styx sound. Their first significant breakthrough came with the album Equinox in 1975, but the real surge in popularity arrived between 1977 and 1983.
During this classic period, Styx released several albums that are still considered staples of classic rock. The Grand Illusion (1977) established the band as a major act, featuring the timeless hit “Come Sail Away” and showcasing their blend of theatrical keyboards, soaring harmonies, and polished rock arrangements. This success continued with Pieces of Eight in 1978, which leaned more heavily on driving guitars and produced radio favorites like “Renegade” and “Blue Collar Man.” In 1979, the band shifted toward a softer, pop-influenced sound with Cornerstone, highlighted by their only #1 single, “Babe.” They reached a peak of musical cohesion with the concept-driven Paradise Theatre in 1981, which topped the Billboard charts and produced hits like “The Best of Times” and “Too Much Time on My Hands.” Their 1983 album, Kilroy Was Here, embraced a synth-heavy, theatrical direction that resulted in the cult hit “Mr. Roboto,” though the album’s ambitious concept contributed to increasing internal tensions.
The Hidden Pressures Behind Styx’s Internal Conflicts
Although most of Styx’s tensions stemmed from differences in musical vision and personality, several outside pressures played a significant role in intensifying friction within the band. Record-label expectations became a major source of strain as A&M Records pushed hard for more radio-friendly ballads following the massive success of “Babe.” This created a growing divide between Dennis DeYoung, who leaned into theatrical, ballad-driven compositions, and Tommy Shaw and James “JY” Young, who preferred a harder, straightforward rock direction. Management choices also contributed to turmoil; as Styx climbed in popularity, the schedules became more demanding, with long, grueling tours and increasingly elaborate stage productions. Many band members later admitted that the constant push to stay on the road made existing disagreements far more volatile.
The ambitious concept behind Kilroy Was Here added another layer of external influence. The album and tour required a huge network of filmmakers, actors, choreographers, and production teams, bringing in far more outside voices than Styx had ever worked with before. The pressure of coordinating such a complex show, paired with rising costs and tighter deadlines, amplified creative disagreements and added stress to an already strained environment. Later, in the late 1990s, health issues affecting Dennis DeYoung became another misunderstood outside factor. His struggles with light sensitivity and chronic fatigue led to delays in touring, and misinformation at the time created rumors that worsened communication between him and the rest of the band. While these tensions were real, much of the conflict was magnified by promoters, scheduling pressures, and misunderstandings fueled by outside expectations.
Styx: Behind the Music, Beyond the Hits
Dennis DeYoung on artistic ambition:
“I pushed them to think about things other than straight‑ahead rock songs … Who are we meeting in the hotel tonight? Let’s party all night. And baby I love you.” Michael Cavacini
Tommy Shaw on the pressure to keep Styx alive:
“I’m very proud of my own era of Styx … For Styx to survive we had to play no less than a hundred shows per year … since then we’ve played well over two thousand shows around the world.” Louder
Lawrence Gowan on the concept behind The Mission:
“To me, The Mission is the story of the band! … You’re all together … working towards an amazing and challenging goal … you see your band mates at their high points and their low points.” Proglodytes
Broader shifts in the musical landscape also indirectly shaped the band’s dynamic. As the 1980s progressed and styles like new wave, synth-pop, and heavier rock gained traction, Styx felt pressure to evolve to stay relevant. This cultural shift partly inspired the theatrical direction of Kilroy, which some members embraced and others resented. Across all of these factors—label demands, management pressure, external production teams, health complications, and changing musical trends—it wasn’t any single rumor or scandal that destabilized Styx. Instead, it was a combination of outside forces that magnified internal disagreements, setting the stage for the major splits that followed.
From Classic Hits to Modern Reinvention
After DeYoung’s departure around 1999–2000, Styx entered a modern era with Lawrence Gowan on vocals and keyboards. The band drew renewed energy from heavy touring and carefully crafted albums that honored their roots while embracing contemporary production. Cyclorama (2003) demonstrated the band’s ability to adapt, incorporating modern rock elements while retaining their signature harmonies and progressive influences. A major creative resurgence came with The Mission (2017), an album praised for capturing the spirit of the band’s late-’70s sound while delivering a fresh, cohesive concept. Crash of the Crown (2021) continued this trend with polished, experimental compositions that proved Styx could still innovate decades into their career.
Styx: A Forward-Thinking Legacy in Rock Music
Styx’s influence extends far beyond chart success. They helped pioneer the concept-album format in mainstream rock, blending storytelling, character-driven narratives, and theatrical presentation. Their integration of keyboards and synthesizers into arena rock influenced the sound of the 1980s, bridging the gap between progressive experimentation and radio-friendly songwriting. Even in the modern era, Styx has remained relevant by staying true to their sound while embracing innovation, producing albums that resonate with both longtime fans and new listeners. Their commitment to touring and performance, along with their ability to adapt to a changing music industry—from vinyl to streaming—demonstrates a forward-thinking approach that has kept the band vibrant for nearly five decades.
Ultimately, Styx’s legacy lies not only in their iconic hits but in their willingness to push the boundaries of rock, blend genres, and experiment with theatrical storytelling. They remain a blueprint for bands seeking to balance commercial success with artistic ambition, proving that creative vision, resilience, and adaptability are as important as talent in building a lasting impact on the music industry.
In the end, Styx’s story is one of both artistic triumph and human complexity. They created music that captured the imagination of millions, including a wide-eyed kid in the backseat of a car in the 1980s who didn’t quite understand the lyrics but knew the sound was extraordinary. Their blend of theatrical flair, melodic mastery, and ambitious storytelling left an indelible mark on rock music, inspiring countless fans and influencing other artists.
At the same time, the band’s history reminds us that even great creative partnerships are vulnerable to outside pressures, shifting trends, and internal disagreements. Yet Styx endured — evolving, adapting, and continuing to perform decades later, proving that talent, resilience, and a strong sense of vision can withstand the tests of time.
Ultimately, it’s the music that endures. Whether it’s the reflective melancholy of “Too Much Time on My Hands”, the soaring drama of “Come Sail Away”, or the experimental curiosity of “Mr. Roboto”, Styx’s legacy is a reminder that art can both capture a moment and continue to inspire long after that moment has passed. For fans old and new, their songs remain a soundtrack to ambition, imagination, and the enduring power of rock itself.
